Tighter loan standards mean the credit crisis isn’t over yet
Investors appear to be increasingly optimistic. Stocks are rallying and the U.S. dollar has rebounded, fueled by growing expectation that the worst of the credit crisis is over and that the economy may even narrowly avoid a recession this year.
But the latest evidence indicates that we’re far from out of the woods yet. 
The Federal Reserve’s latest Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey released Monday showed banks dramatically tightened lending standards across all categories between January and April, citing “a less favorable or more uncertain economic outlook.” The percentages of banks reporting tighter lending standards “were close to, or above, historical highs for nearly all loan categories,” according to the survey, which covers both business and consumer lending.
Deteriorating loan performance is causing banks to increase premiums for riskier loans, loan covenants and collateral requirements. Aaron Smith, an economist at Moody’s Economy.com, argued that lending standards are now tighter on most forms of credit than at any time in the past 50 years. The most dramatic change in lending standards was for business loans, he said, as a net 55.4% of banks reported tighter conditions for commercial and industrial loans to large and midsized firms, up from 32.2% in the prior survey.
The reduced access to credit by both firms and consumers may prove to be the biggest downside risk to the economy. The most recent data on tightening credit conditions for commercial & industrial loans showed “meaningful worsening of credit conditions” and argue “forcefully that a classic recession is in place based on past experience, contradicting sanguine views that a recession will be averted,” said Citigroup Tobias Levkovich.
Credit leads the real economy and there’s usually a three-quarter lag between credit standards and corporate investment in human, working, and physical capital, Levkovich said. As a result, given the tougher credit environment, the lag, and the tight relationship between production and earnings, “it would seem very realistic to assume that more cyclical earnings estimates face substantive downward guidance with equity market implications.”



Markets-hub.com